Two Top 14 sides made certain of their places in the post-season race for the Bouclier de Brennus, leaving eight teams chasing four still-open slots. At the other end of the table, relegation matters were decided
After the fireworks of ProD2 final Friday, the French top flight kicked up a storm to remind potential TV rights bidders just what they’ll be paying for between 2027 and 2031, after this week’s tender submission deadline.
READ ALSO TV deal to break €500m barrier
As the Top 14 crashed through the 900-try barrier for the season and screamed ever nearer to the 8,000-point mark, one side claimed a direct pass to a semi-final in Bordeaux; and another staked a certain claim to a top-six play-off spot, leaving up to eight teams fighting for the four remaining post-season knockout places.
At the other end of the table, automatic relegation and survival play-off teams were confirmed on a decisive day at the business end of the season.
But, if you’re a Leinster fan here looking for news on how Toulouse’s stars got on in their final Top 14 match before Saturday’s Champions Cup final, there’s what could be some bad news in store.
Results
Clermont’s late-season revival and Racing’s late-season slow-death both continue, while Bayonne and Lyon both won big matches at home – while Montpellier and Oyonnax both lost games they really had to win. Here are the results from the 23rd weekend of the Top 14 season.
Match of the weekend: Stade Francais 22 Bordeaux 18
Second-in-the-table Stade Francais have one hand on a semi-final pass, and both on a play-off place, after a hard-fought pragmatism-first win over third-placed Bordeaux in front of a crowd of more than 19,000 at Stade Jean Bouin.
As fullback Leo Barre said: “We’ve got a toe in the semi-finals, but we’re not there yet.”
It was a match players and coaches alike had described, in various ways, as a must-win – and a much-needed one after two defeats on the bounce saw them lose their long-held position at the top of the table to reigning Top 14 champions Toulouse.
It was also a match in which 37-year-old scrum-half Rory Kockott – one-time senior-player mentor to both Antoine Dupont and Santiago Arata – rolled back the years, pulled strings, managed players and scored a crucial try as the hosts quickly recovered after shipping an early lead.
He, and fly-half Joris Segonds – who scored his first-ever Top 14 try in his 107th Top 14 match and also broke the 1,000 club points barrier, weeks before he switches club allegiances to Bayonne – had the better of international opposite numbers Maxime Lucu and Matthieu Jalibert.
Bordeaux, for all their off-the-scale attacking flair, found Paul Gustard’s defensive structures difficult to break down. It wasn’t for lack of effort – centre Ben Tapuai opened the scoring in the 8th minute, and Romain Latterrade added a second just before halftime.
A forward pass ruled out an early second-half score for Louis Bielle-Biarrey; the referee was an unwitting obstacle in another breakout move; Pete Samu was stopped just short of the line; then Toma Taufa was prevented from grounding the ball in the in-goal area eight minutes from time; Leo Barre beat Lucu to the ball in the Stade scoring zone two minutes later.
It’s not the effort that matters, or the chances created, but the chances taken. Stade’s defence mostly held. They outscored their opponents’ vaunted attack three tries to two – Jeremy Ward adding his name to the list in the 55th minute – as they made hay while the visitors’ mounting frustration shone.
Bordeaux manager Yannick Bru called for Jalibert to kick a penalty for the losing bonus point three minutes from time. It was a sensible and pragmatic decision and the one time they played Stade’s game – otherwise they would have left with nothing.
READ ALSO Top 14 Saturday round-up
Individual performance
Mathis Castro-Ferreira. The 20-year-old missed Toulouse training this week because he was revising for a crucial exam – as were two of his team-mates.
The day after sitting it, he scored twice in the first-half of Toulouse’s win over Montpellier that first ensured a play-off spot and then, thanks to results elsewhere, confirmed a semi-final place in Bordeaux at the back end of June.
Flop
Racing 92 get this week’s flop nod for longer-term reasons, just slightly ahead – or behind, depending on your viewpoint – of Montpellier. Canal Plus pointed out a surprising stat at the weekend: since the halfway point of the season, Stuart Lancaster’s side have the second-worst record of any side in the Top 14.
And three defeats on the bounce have left them hanging on to the sixth and final play-off spot. That leaves a proud record in serious danger: Racing have not missed a Top 14 play-off since 2010. But they’re just a point ahead of Pau and Clermont, and two clear of Perpignan and Castres.
They were at Lyon on Saturday, a side admittedly difficult to beat at home, and who secured Top 14 status next season with their 11th win at Stade Gerland.
But Racing had their chances, notably at the end of the game, with the score at 20-14 in the hosts’ favour. Racing battered away at Lyon’s line, with the clock deep in the red, and Josua Tuisova dived over, only for Felix Lambey to snatch the ball out of his hands just before he got it down.
This is what the win meant to the home side.
Nolan Le Garrec told broadcaster Canal Plus immediately afterwards: “It was hard for us today. We showed character, but it wasn’t enough. The championship’s not over yet, and we’ve got to keep our heads up.”
He wasn’t kidding: Racing are at home (read at Auxerre) to seventh-placed Pau on June 1, then travel to La Rochelle for the final round of the season a week later. That’s not a final fortnight fixture list for a faint-hearted side that have lost 12 of their 16 matches in 2024.
Coaching call
Clermont’s usually fairly conservative manager Christophe Urios has a reputation for occasionally doing the unexpected. On Saturday, for no immediately apparent reason, he swapped out his entire front row after half an hour of their 36-20 bonus-point win over Castres.
The starting trio didn’t seem to have done much wrong in the first 30 minutes. They weren’t being blown away at the set piece, and Clermont were 17-3 up.
As a coaching switch-up, it didn’t do any harm, clearly. But it was hard to see during the game what purpose it served. There was no clear uptick in performance. The difference it made was, it seems, in hearts and minds rather than in performance and points.
Urios felt, he said afterwards, that his starting squad ‘lacked freshness’ after a long, unbroken block of games. He described them as ‘mentally exhausted’.
“I sensed it in the warm-up,” he said. “We were sluggish. At the start of the match, you hope it’s going to fade away, but in fact it didn’t … if I could have pulled eight players, I would have.”
Clermont won, picked up a bonus point, and – at the end of a season at Marcel Michelin that’s been more difficult than it perhaps should have been – have an unlikely shot at the top six. Go figure.
Talking point
Toulouse coach Ugo Mola rested almost every one of his ‘executive’ squad for the final Top 14 match – a trip to Montpellier – before the Champions Cup final in London.
According to Canal, the average age of the Toulouse 23 at the GGL was around 24. And it included Piula Fa’asalele, who’s 36, and Richie Arnold, who’s 33.
But there was no Antoine Dupont or Romain Ntamack, whose on-pitch appearances this week were limited to a parade around Stade Ernest Wallon with the Olympic flame. There was no Cyril Baille, or Julien Marchand; no Peato Mauvaka, Dorian Aldegheri, Emmanuel Meafou or Thibaud Flament. Francois Cros and Alexandre Roumat stayed at home – as did Thomas Ramos, Paul Graou, Pita Ahki, Mathis Lebel, and Paul Costes.
Dupont got no gametime last week, either, watching from the subs’ bench as Graou carved Stade Francais apart. That means he’s fresh – and no little frustrated – heading into Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.
And, still, Mola’s Babes beat Montpellier 29-22 at the GGL. They were leading 26-7 after half an hour, and played utterly fearless rugby all afternoon. Even after Montpellier roared back at them – two Cobus Reinach tries got the score back to 26-22 at halftime – they showed huge strength of character and defensive nous to nil them in the second half.
It was, as assistant coach Laurent Thuery said afterwards, “frankly … magnificent.”
He went on: “We had no regrets. We had to play our rugby, and dare to try things. We knew Montpellier were going to be intense… But in all honesty, bravo! I take my hat off to the players. They showed genuine attacking qualities, a magnificent state of mind, and great solidarity.”
Quote of the week
“We have to tell the lads that in four weeks’ time that we have something to do – a match with a colossal stakes. We won’t be playing for a title, but to maintain an institution in Top 14. We’ve got a month to try and stop playing against ourselves and beating ourselves up.”
Montpellier manager Patrice Collazo after that loss to Toulouse condemned them to a survival play-off against the losing ProD2 finalist on June 16.
Collazo and his crack team of coaches oversaw seven wins in their first 11 Top 14 matches after joining Montpellier in November. But, since they were hammered 54-7 at Toulon on March 23, they’ve picked up just three points out of a possible 30.
Still, it could have been worse: Toulon’s 27-17 win at Oyonnax at least meant the 2022 Top 14 champions cannot finish at the bottom of the table and be automatically relegated.
Small mercies, and all that.
Table
Here’s that Top 14 table after 24 of 26 rounds.
Toulouse can finish no lower than second, guaranteeing themselves a direct path from the final weekend of the season on June 8 to the semi-finals in Bordeaux a fortnight later.
Stade Francais have the upper hand in the race for the second semi-final pass, with teams as far down as Castres in 10th having a decreasingly likely shot at the post-season. Bayonne and Lyon, meanwhile made certain of Top 14 rugby next season.
My name is James Harrington. I’m a freelance sports journalist, writing mostly about French club and international rugby. If, after reading this, you feel the urge to commission me for match previews, reviews, articles, news, features, interviews, live blogs, feel free to contact me
And, please read my weekly French rugby column in The Rugby Paper every Sunday. And I also round-up all the weekend’s Top 14 action on the Irish Examiner website.